Menu of Main Street Pizza in Reynoldsville, Pennsylvania, USA

Menu Overview

Main Street Pizza, located at 474 E Main St in Reynoldsville, PA, is a local gem that serves up a diverse and satisfying menu centered around classic and specialty pizzas, alongside some exceptional wings and hearty sides. From my experience and various customer insights, this spot effortlessly balances quality, flavor, and value, making it a worthwhile destination for pizza lovers and wing enthusiasts alike.

Their pizza offerings are robust and customizable, ranging from mini 6-inch options perfect for a light snack to large 16-inch pies ideal for sharing. I was particularly impressed by the Small Chicken Bacon Ranch and the Small Steak Rancher pizzas. Both delivered a satisfying blend of fresh toppings, rich sauces, and well-melted cheese. The cheese itself is notably thick and gooey, contributing to a comforting bite. The pizza sauce leans toward a classic, tangy profile that complements the generous toppings without overpowering them.

Specialty pizzas such as the Deluxe, Meaty, and Texas Ra add depth and excitement to the menu. Although some variation in the cooking consistency has been noted—like a slightly doughy bottom crust in certain instances—it doesn’t diminish the overall enjoyment. Ordering a slice by the piece (available until 2 pm on weekdays) is a fantastic, budget-friendly way to sample their pizza craftsmanship.

However, the true stars of Main Street Pizza’s menu are their wings and Stromboli. The dinner conversation frequently turns to the Garlic Parmesan Wings and Jumbo Wings, both praised for being crispy, flavorful, and generously portioned. The wings tend to be fall-off-the-bone tender, especially the boneless variety, which many rave about for their moistness and burst of flavor. These wings stand out as some of the best you’ll find at a fair price point in the area. For those who enjoy something a little different, the BBQ Chicken Pizza offers a sweet and smoky twist, although individual preferences may vary, as one customer found the buffalo chicken variant a bit too reminiscent of BBQ.

Aside from pizza and wings, the menu includes tasty sides like steak wedgies and mini tacos, which add variety and cater to different cravings, enhancing the overall dining experience. Plus, the presence of party trays and half trays makes Main Street Pizza a go-to spot for gatherings and events, offering convenience alongside generous portions.

Customer service here stands out as well, with repeated mentions of helpful, polite, and friendly staff who enhance the dining experience. The establishment makes ordering straightforward, with reasonable wait times and accessible parking, reinforcing its appeal as a community staple.

In summary, Main Street Pizza excels at delivering familiar yet satisfying flavors across pizzas and wings, with particular praise deserved by their Garlic Parmesan Wings and the robust cheesiness of their pies. While minor inconsistencies exist, the quality, pricing, and service create a compelling reason to visit or order from them. Whether you're grabbing a quick slice, ordering a specialty pizza, or indulging in their celebrated wings, Main Street Pizza promises a rewarding meal with genuine small-town charm.